History of Garhwal King Medni Shah
History of Garhwal including Haridwar (1223- 1804 AD) –part -152
History of Uttarakhand (Garhwal, Kumaon and Haridwar) -399
By: Bhishma Kukreti (A History Research Student)
There are disagreements between historians Dabral and Ajay Rawat about death of Medni Shah and death of Prithvipati Shah. Dabral states that the year of death of Prithvipati must be 1664. Ajay Rawat refers the Farman from Aurangzeb to Prithvipati Shah of 1662 refers about death of Medni Shah the son of Prithvipati Shah. Same way Ajay Rawat argued that Prithvipati Shah was alive till 1667 as there is seal of Prithvipati Shah in a copper inscription.
It is sure that Medni Shah dethroned his father from Kingship before November 1660. Medni Shah was more practical than his father. Mughal Army and its alliances Army were highly powerful than Garhwal Army. Medni Shah might have concluded after consulting his ministers and well wishers that it was dangerous to resist Aurungzeb’s order about handing over of Suleiman Shikoh to Aurungzeb.
Letter to Jai Singh
Medni Shah sent a letter to King jai Singh that he was agreed to hand over Suleiman Shikoh to the Mughal.
Arrival of Ram Singh in Garhwal Region
On 12 December 1660, Aurungzeb sent Ram Singh (son of Jai Singh) to Bhabhar Garhwal (Sarkar, History of Aurungzeb) for bringing Suleiman Shikoh. However, Raturi states that Ram Singh reached to Shrinagar and met Medni Shah and Prithvipati Shah. Prithvipati Shah was still ready to offer asylum to Suleiman Shikoh. However, Prithvipati was helpless.
Suleiman Shikoh came to know the conspiracy of Medni Shah and Ram Singh. In night, Suleiman Shikoh ran towards Tibet. However, not aware about Tibet road he hid in a cave near Shrinagar. A shepherd informed to Medni Shah about Suleiman hiding in a cave. According to Muslim writers Garhwal army followed Suleiman and Suleiman and his supporter fought with Garhwal army but lost the mini battle. Soldiers caught Suleiman Shikoh.
However, Muslim historians or memoir writers do not vouch that Ram Singh reached to Shrinagar. Maularam also supports that Ram Singh did not reach to Shrinagar. Medni Shah came to Bhabhar near present Kotdwara and handed over Mughal Prince Suleiman Shikoh on 27th December 1660. The said information reached to Aurungzeb on 29th December 1660. Getting information, pleased Aurungzeb offered a gemmed Turra to Jay Sing the father of Ram Singh.
Ram Singh, Tarbiyat Khan, Radandaj Khan and other Mansabdar (commanders or heads) reached Delhi with Suleiman Shikoh on 2nd January 1661. Suleiman Shikoh was put in Jail near Salimgarh with Muhammad Sultan the son of Aurungzeb. Muhammad Sultan opposed Aurungzeb with Shuza and Aurungzeb put his son in Jail.
Muslim Memoir books as Muaasir al Umara etc state that Medni Shah was also with Ram Singh up to Delhi. Aurungzeb pardoned Garhwal Kingdom.
Folklore of Shrinagar Garhwal about Suleiman Shikoh
Maularam was born after eighty years of the above incidents. He created a book Gadhrajvnsh Kavya. Dr Dabral got the manuscript from Baijnath Tomar the great grandson of Maularam in Shrinagar Garhwal. The poetry starts from Suleiman Shikoh. However, unfortunately, two first pages are missing from the said manuscript. Dr Dabral published the poetry and other literature of Maularam.
Maularm took clue from folklore famous in Shrinagar. By mistake, Maularam wrote Jahangir instead of Shahjahan and Fate Shah instead of Prithvipati Shah.
Medni Shah sent letter to Aurungzeb and Aurungzeb sent his army to capture Suleiman Shikoh. Aurungzeb threatened Garhwal King to hand over Suleiman otherwise he would capture Pataldun or Bhabhar.
Taking Suleiman to Bhabhar
Getting letter from Aurungzeb, Medni Shah consulted his confident ministers. The Khas minister advised to take Suleiman by force to the commander of Aurungzeb. The Brahmin minster advised not to hand over Suleiman Shikoh to Aurangzeb. Brahmin ministers advised to take Suleiman Shikoh through diplomatic means.
At the end, Medni Shah went to Suleiman Shikoh and told him that Mughal army captured Bhabhar and Garhwal army was unable to fight without leader. Medni Shah told that he (Medni) had to reach Bhabhar. Medni Shah told Suleiman to come Bhabhar with him. The chief minister of Suleiman advised Suleiman not to go Bhabhar but Suleiman agreed to go along with Medni Shah.
Medni Shah told Suleiman Shikoh to march towards Pataldun (Bhabhar). Medni Shah assured that just after Suleiman his Diwan/ chief minister, wife, Harem women and other servants would follow. Suleiman Shikoh marched towards Bhabhar. As soon as Suleiman Shikoh reached at Bhabhar, he was handed over to Mughal Army.
Cursing by Suleiman Shikoh
When Medni Shah handed over Suleiman Shikoh to Mughal Army Suleiman Shikoh felt sorry for the deceptive method of Garhwal King. Suleiman Shikoh cursed Garhwal King that his Kingdom would be ruined very shortly. Suleiman cursed that there would be many calamities, disturbances in Garhwal and Garhwal would be in poor conditions.
Medni Shah returned to Shrinagar after handing over Suleiman Shikoh to Mughal Army.
Who was Responsible for Handing over Suleiman Shikoh to Mughal Army?
According to Muslim memoir writers Ram Singh did not visit Shrinagar Garhwal to take Suleiman Shikoh. Muslim historians state that Garhwal King sent Suleiman Shikoh to Bhabhar with his son Medni Shah (Kafi Khan –Multakhbul- Lubab and Mua’asir –ul-Umara). Muslim writers credit to Prithvipati Shah handing over to Muslim Army by deceptive manner. However, historian Quanungo argued that Prithvipati Singh would not do as he would have handed Suleiman Shikoh at initial stage. Qanungo believed that Prithvipati Singh was not party betraying Suleiman Shikoh.
Maularam stated wrongly Fateshah (son of Medni Shah) betraying Suleiman Shikoh. However, Maularam also accepted that Aurungzeb returned Doon valley to Garhwal in the period of Medni Shah.
Award to Saubhagya/Subhag Prakash
Aurungzeb did not return Doon valley to Garhwal Kingdom for a few years after his being Mughal Emperor. In 1661, Aurungzeb handed over rule of Kalakhar region to Sirmaur King Saubhagya or Subhag Prakash. Perhaps Kalakhar region is present Kaulagarh of Dehradun.
Crowning of Medni Shah?
According to Dabral, Raturi and British historians, Medni Shah was crowned officially in 1664 after death of his father Prithvi Pat Shah. While offering a Farman from Aurungzeb, Ajay Rawat state that Medni Shah died in 1662 in Delhi. Aurungzeb sent a Farman to Prithvipati Singh in 1662.
Sheltering Ministers of Suleiman Shikoh in Shrinagar Garhwal
It is said that Medni Shah sent the Begum (wife), women and other private servants of Suleiman Shikoh to Bhabhar after some time. However, he put Ministers as Shyam Das and his son Kehri Das and other administrative officers into prison. Later on Medni Shah made them understand that if they go to Delhi Aurungzeb would put them in prison. Medni Shah arranged stiffened for them. Later on Medni Shah freed them and appointed them in court employment. Maularam was great grandson of Shyam Das.
Aurangzeb ordering Medni Shah to win Butaulgarh and History Aspects of Butaula Negi
Garhwal King Medni Shah went to Mughal Court before Aurungzeb asp er Emperor Order. According to Maularam, Medni Shah handed over his rule to his son Fateh Shah. Aurungzeb ordered Medni Shah to capture Butolgarh. Before that Mughal army was failure in winning Butolgarh. Mukandilal mentioned Kyunthalgarh of Himachal instead Butaul Garh (Hindustani Patrika) . Muslim historians did not state anything about Aurangzeb ordering Medni Shah for capturing Butaul Garh.
Campaign of Capturing Butaul Garh
As per order of Aurungzeb, Medni Shah ordered his army to march for Butaulgarh. In front, there were Khasiya labor soldiers. They were carrying Sattu (roasted cereal flour), roasted cereals, wodden plates. They were carrying water in tumadis (calabash). Khasiya labor soldiers were also carrying bedding and hemp sheets for protecting Sattu etc.
Marcha (Tibetan origin) soldiers were after Khasia soldiers. Marcha soldiers were carrying arrows, javelins and axes. There were soldiers from Lohaba and Badhan. Those soldiers were having guns in their hands. The soldiers were marching with enthusiasm. Medni Shah was leading enthusiastic army.
Since, the army did not have Deswal, Salani and Dilwal soldiers it is obvious that Butaulgarh was a hill region. A Tunwar commander was leading the army.
The Opposite Army – The opposite army resembled a half armed mob, rather than a military force. The soldiers did not have army uniform, each soldier was having arms as per his circumstances, some with matchlock, some with swords and those were not having any arm they were possessing sticks and tree branches (JAS of Bengal, vol-8). Garhwal army was also same as opposite army.
Surrounding Butaulgarh- Garhwal army surrounded Butaul Garh. Medni Shah ordered to stop food and water supply for fort. He also ordered his men not to communicate with people inside the Garh or fort. A few armed forces entered into Garh and beheaded the soldiers of Butaul Garh. Balance soldiers surrender before Medni Shah. In the name of Mughal Empire, Medni Shah captured Butaul Garh. He informed the capturing of Butaul Garh to Aurangzeb.
Awarding to Commander- Tunwar was the army commander of the campaign. Medni Shah was pleased by the win. Medni Shah offered a silver inscription to Tunwar commander. Medni Shah offered Tunwar commander as Butaula Negi. Butaula Negi of Garhwal are successor of that Tunwar commander. Tunwar commander was successor of Banarasi Das Tunvar who fought against Kumaoni army from Garhwal army in past.
Order for Doon Valley under Garhwal Kingdom
Aurangzeb invited Medni Shah to Delhi after getting information he capturing Butaula Garh. In Delhi, Mughal administration welcomed him with great honor. Aurangzeb asked the demand of Medni Shah. Medni Shah requested to get Doon valley free from Mughal rule. Aurungzeb ordered the rule of Garhwal over Doon valley. Now Doon valley was under Garhwal.
Medni Shah residing in Delhi
Aurungzeb was influenced by Medni Shah and he told him to stay in Delhi. Medni Shah used to visit Mughal court daily.
Maularam wrote that Garhwal king returned Delhi (he wrote wrong names). However, Ajay Rawat argued that Medni Shah died in Delhi in 1662 for his treachery.
Dr Dabral stressed more on Garhrajvansh Kavya of Maularam for mentioning history of Medni Shah. While other historians as Rawat, handa etc did not write much about Medni Shah.
Copyright@ Bhishma Kukreti Mumbai, India, bckukreti@gmail.com 6/8/2014
History of Garhwal – Kumaon-Haridwar (Uttarakhand, India) to be continued… Part -400
(The History of Garhwal, Kumaon, Haridwar write up is aimed for general readers)
History of Garhwal from 1223-1804 to be continued in next chapter ….
XX
Notes on South Asian Medieval History of Garhwal; SouthAsian Medieval History of Pauri Garhwal; Medieval History of Chamoli Garhwal; South Asian Medieval History of Rudraprayag Garhwal; South Asian Medieval History of Tehri Garhwal; Medieval History of Uttarkashi Garhwal; South Asian Medieval History of Dehradun, Garhwal; Medieval History of Haridwar ; South Asian Medieval History of Manglaur, Haridwar; South Asian Medieval History of Rurkee Haridwar ; South Asian Medieval History of Bahadarpur Haridwar ; South Asian History of Haridwar district to be continued
XX